Am I a Hoarder or Just Messy? How to Tell the Difference

Have you ever said, "Ugh, I'm such a hoarder," when scooping up a stack of mail off a chair so a friend could sit down?

‍

Or made the joke yourself, before anyone else had the chance to make it for you?

‍

Or looked at yourself in the mirror and told yourself you’re pathetic or a loser or something equally mean and disparaging?

‍

How about finding yourself still awake at 2:00 AM, wondering if there’s anything funny about having hoarding tendencies or if your worst fears are true?

‍

"Am I a hoarder or just messy?" is a question people type into Google, word for word.

‍

So here's the short answer.

‍

If you can still use your rooms for what they're meant for, and letting go of things feels annoying rather than unbearable, you're most likely dealing with clutter, not hoarding disorder.

‍

Hoarding disorder is a recognized mental health condition listed in the DSM-5, and I've already written about what it is—and what it isn't—in Plain Talk About Hoarding Tendencies.

‍

This post picks up where that one left off.

‍

Because once you've ruled out hoarding, you're left with a harder question.

‍

“If this isn't the result of a disorder, what is wrong with me and why does my home still look like this?”

HOW DO I KNOW IF I'M A HOARDER?

Start with something simple.

‍

Can you sit down and eat dinner at your table tonight without having to move things out of the way?

‍

And if you do, are they small things like the mail or your cell phone?

‍

Or bigger things like a laundry basket, a few delivery boxes, or a stack of magazines and catalogs you’ve been meaning to go through for at least a couple of months?

‍

Good news, big or small, all of that is clutter.

‍

And while it's frustrating, and maybe a little embarrassing, you could fix any of it before the pasta water finishes boiling.

‍

So, then ask yourself another question.

‍

Would you let a friend in tonight, even if you kept apologizing the whole time they were there?

‍

If the answer is yes, you're still most likely dealing with clutter.

‍

If the table hasn't been usable in years, if the room itself is difficult to walk into or out of, and you've stopped letting anyone visit, skip ahead to the section on getting help and please read it twice.

WHY AM I SO MESSY?

Here's the thing about the word messy.

‍

It sounds mildly negative and like a built-in trait or characteristic, the way some people are tall and we call them giants, or left-handed and we call them sinister, or a ginger and we call them Prince Harry.

‍

But messy isn’t like being hairy or short or having six toes.

‍

Because clutter is mostly decisions you've deferred—it’s behavioral.

‍

You set it down or you stuffed it someplace and kept walking.

‍

Probably meaning to deal with it “later.”

‍

Which could be that sweater your ex gave you that’s really soft and cozy even though they aren’t.

‍

Or the Covid-era bread machine you got on a whim that is still unopened in the garage, like most pandemic inspirations.

‍

Or that hideous platter from your sister you know you should use but it literally makes you gag when you see it.

‍

Or those boxes from your childhood home that are perched on a shelf in the garage because opening them means going back to a time that didn’t feel great the first time you lived it.

‍

None of that makes you a hoarder, and it doesn't make you a messy person either.

‍

It makes you someone with a backlog of decisions and a bunch of feelings.

‍

Now if instead, you drop your clothes on the floor instead of hanging them up on the closet door or a hook or tossing them on that chair in the corner of your bedroom …

‍

If you eat dinner on the sofa and leave the carryout food containers on the coffee table for 5 days even though you’ve been by the trash at least 20 times since then …

‍

If you let the cat box pile up long after you can smell that the litter needs changing …

‍

You either didn’t learn some basic self-care when you were growing up …

‍

Or you are unconsciously reacting to an overly controlling parent who made self-care feel like punishment …

‍

Or you’re possibly depressed.

‍

So you could be lacking some fundamental instruction on how to care for your home and yourself …

‍

Or checked out from its significance and usefulness.

‍

Either way, the annoying twist is that any of these tasks or chores are so less demanding of your attention and energy than ignoring them and by extension ignoring yourself.

‍

And I promise you, your worst fear about what you'll find when you finally take action is almost always 100x worse than how it feels when you move that first muscle.

‍

Non-action keeps the discomfort vague but acute.

‍

And action makes any discomfort clear and often less intense.

‍

See? Kind of ironic … and annoying.

HOW DO I STOP BEING MESSY?

Let’s start by looking at the previous examples.

‍

Then check in with yourself.

‍

Are you depressed?

‍

Feeling blue for longer than a few hours or even days?

‍

If so, please seek some help you’d be willing to accept.

‍

Either from a mental health counselor or some other provider.

‍

The NAMI HelpLine is a free, confidential place to start—call 1-800-950-6264 or text NAMI to 62640, Monday through Friday, 10:00am–10:00pm Eastern.

‍

If you’re in crisis, call or text 988 anytime.

‍

If there are no underlying symptoms, the fastest way to stop being messy is retracing the steps you took to get here, one decision at a time.

‍

So, set a timer for 15 minutes and start with one surface or category of stuff.

‍

Sort like with like first.

‍

That means loose mail goes with loose mail, and pens with pens.

‍

Once they're all together, side by side, it's a lot easier to see how much you own, and which ones deserve to stay.

‍

As you’re deciding which things stay, start by asking yourself if you’d buy the thing today and whether you’d use it or could let it go and not really miss it.

‍

Then give everything that stays its one home.

‍

That's the first rule of the Organizational Triangle®: One home for everything.

‍

While you’re doing this work, stuff may look bigger before it gets better, but it is the exact same amount of stuff, just spread out where you can finally see it.

‍

By the way, as someone who has worked in people’s homes and offices for over 3 decades, I can tell you that I never tell my clients what to keep or let go of.

‍

I’m there to coach them and help them make decisions for themselves.

‍

And while I’m sort of coaching you right now, if this feels a bit overwhelming and you're not sure where to begin, I wrote about where to start decluttering when everything feels like too much.

‍

I also have a program on Skool that is designed to help you with this exact problem.

‍

You can find out more here: https://www.skool.com/unstuff-your-life/about

WHEN SHOULD I GET HELP FOR HOARDING?

If your answers to the earlier questions point the other way, and your home has really ceased to be functional on a fundamental level, please don't wait to seek some sort of help.

‍

Talk with a mental health professional who has experience with hoarding disorder.

‍

The International OCD Foundation's hoarding center is a good place to start.

‍

And then, you and I can discuss possible private onsite work or you can look for someone else to support you.

‍

Just know that while talk therapy is a tremendous tool in addressing hoarding disorder, no amount of talk will move a single thing in your home.

‍

So a combo approach involving some form of talk therapy and onsite assistance is often the quickest path forward.

‍

I have helped many people with hoarding disorder when they have an honest desire for things to change.

‍

If you're reading this and worried about someone you love, you may also want to check out these additional articles about helping a loved one who holds on to too much and living with someone who won't deal with their clutter.

READY TO CLEAR THAT TABLE FOR DINNER?

Whether you’re a bit messy, someone with hoarding tendencies, or overwhelmed with too many historic decisions now stacked up on the table … dinner sitting down is within reach.

‍

Forget counting how many times you’ve cleared the table only to watch it fill back up by Friday.

‍

What’s done is done.

‍

Which is exactly why I built our new Unstuff Your Life! Community on Skool.

‍

Inside it, you get daily, Monday through Friday community coaching so you can get real support.

‍

You also get 2x a month live 90-minute Get-It-Done sessions, where everyone works on their own projects at the same time.

‍

There are over 60 hours in the Open Office Hours archive, sorted by stuff topic.

‍

And workshops on paper, digital clutter, photos, calendars, and other tasks as they are needed.

‍

The first 100 members get in at $67 a month, and that price stays locked in for as long as you stay.

‍

And here’s my promise to you: You’ll get 4 hours of your life back in 30 days—or your first month is free.

‍

Get 4 hours of your life back here →

‍

Start by setting a timer for 15 minutes.

‍

Clear the table … or take another simple action.

‍

Then celebrate when the timer goes off.

‍

It really is that simple.